My Thanksgiving Pie Day Plan: Two Pies, One Afternoon, and a Timeline That Actually Works

For years I did holiday baking the way a lot of moms do: a pie crust one night, a batch of cookies the next, a pan of bars at 10 p.m. on a school night. The kitchen was never clean that week, and neither was I.

Now I pick one day and do it all at once. The oven stays hot all day, and the mixer gets washed once instead of five times.

Anything we won’t eat that week goes into the same freezer system I use for dinners. And if these recipes make more than your crowd needs, my recipe scaler cuts every amount in half without the mental math.

Thanksgiving Pie Day

Two pies is the right number at our table: one pumpkin, one apple with a crumb top. If you’re cooking the whole meal for a small group, pie day fits into my Thanksgiving for four timeline.

The week of pie day, dinner comes right off my November meal plan, so I’m not making a single other decision in the kitchen.

Two Days Out: Make the Dough

Tuesday is dough day. I make one batch of the crust below, which gives me two discs, and they rest in the fridge until Wednesday afternoon.

While the butter’s out, I also mix the crumb topping for the apple pie and refrigerate it. Then I buy the apples, a mix of tart and sweet, because a pie made with one kind tastes flat to me.

A firm, tart green apple keeps its shape in the oven, and a sweeter red one softens around it into something close to sauce. Half and half is my usual split, and I skip any variety that turns mealy when you bite into it raw.

All-Butter Pie Crust (Makes Two)

I believe in butter, and pie crust is where that belief earns its keep. This one browns well and flakes apart without any shortening.

Makes: two 9-inch crusts  |  Prep: 15 minutes  |  Chill: at least 1 hour

Ingredients

  • 2 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
  • 1 tablespoon sugar
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • 1 cup (2 sticks) cold unsalted butter, cut into 1/2-inch cubes
  • 6 to 8 tablespoons ice water

Instructions

  1. Whisk the flour, sugar, and salt in a large bowl.
  2. Add the butter and work it in with your fingertips or two forks until most pieces are the size of peas, with a few larger flat bits left.
  3. Drizzle in 6 tablespoons of ice water and toss with a fork. Add more water a tablespoon at a time, just until the dough holds together when you squeeze a handful.
  4. Divide the dough in half, press each half into a 1-inch-thick disc, and wrap tightly.
  5. Chill at least 1 hour, or up to 2 days.
  6. To roll, let a disc sit out 5 to 10 minutes. Roll it on a floured counter into a 12- to 13-inch circle, ease it into a 9-inch deep-dish pie plate, trim to a 1-inch overhang, then fold the edge under and crimp.

If the dough cracks at the edges while you roll, it’s too cold, so give it a few more minutes at room temperature. If it turns greasy and sticks, it’s too warm, and 10 minutes of chilling fixes it. Tears get patched with a scrap pressed on top, and the filling hides it.

The Day Before: Bake Both Pies

Wednesday afternoon is the main event. One oven handles both pies, and on this schedule the second one comes out around 4:15.

TimeOvenOn the counter
1:00OffRoll both crusts, fit them into pie plates, crimp, and chill 30 minutes
1:30Heat to 425°FMix the pumpkin filling
2:00Pumpkin pie inPeel and slice the apples
2:15Lower to 350°FToss the apples with sugar and spices
About 3:00Pumpkin pie out; heat to 400°FCool the pumpkin pie on a rack; fill the apple pie and add the crumb topping
3:15Apple pie inStart the dishes
3:35Lower to 375°FMove the pumpkin pie to the fridge once it’s cool
About 4:15Apple pie outCool it on a rack for at least 2 hours
Pumpkin pie being prepared at home

Pumpkin Pie Filling

This is a classic custard filling, and I don’t fuss with it much. My one change is brown sugar instead of white, because it tastes deeper next to the spices.

People ask whether I roast a fresh pumpkin for this. I did once, and the canned puree won. It’s smoother, and it doesn’t cost me an afternoon.

Makes: one 9-inch deep-dish pie  |  Prep: 10 minutes  |  Bake: 55 to 65 minutes

Ingredients

  • 1 (15-ounce) can pumpkin puree (not pumpkin pie filling)
  • 3/4 cup packed brown sugar
  • 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
  • 1/2 teaspoon ground ginger
  • 1/4 teaspoon ground cloves
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 2 large eggs
  • 1 (12-ounce) can evaporated milk
  • 1 unbaked pie crust, chilled in its pie plate

Instructions

  1. Heat the oven to 425°F with a rack in the lower third.
  2. Whisk the pumpkin, brown sugar, spices, and salt in a large bowl.
  3. Whisk in the eggs, then the evaporated milk, until smooth.
  4. Set the chilled crust on a sheet pan and pour in the filling.
  5. Bake 15 minutes at 425°F, then lower the oven to 350°F and bake 40 to 50 minutes more. It’s done when the edges are set, the center still jiggles a little, and a knife inserted about 1 inch from the center comes out clean.
  6. If the crust edge darkens before the filling sets, cover it loosely with strips of foil.
  7. Cool on a rack, then refrigerate within 2 hours of baking.

Apple Crumb Pie Filling

I gave up on lattice tops years ago. A crumb topping takes five minutes and never shrinks away from the edge. My family likes it better anyway.

Makes: one 9-inch deep-dish pie  |  Prep: 25 minutes  |  Bake: 55 to 65 minutes

Ingredients

  • About 3 pounds apples (6 to 7 medium), peeled, cored, and sliced 1/4 inch thick
  • 1/2 cup granulated sugar
  • 2 tablespoons all-purpose flour
  • 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
  • 1 tablespoon lemon juice
  • Pinch of salt
  • 1 unbaked pie crust, chilled in its pie plate
  • For the crumb topping: 3/4 cup all-purpose flour, 1/2 cup packed brown sugar, 1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon, a pinch of salt, and 6 tablespoons cold butter, cubed

Instructions

  1. Heat the oven to 400°F with a rack in the lower third.
  2. If you didn’t make the topping ahead, rub the cold butter into the flour, brown sugar, cinnamon, and salt with your fingertips until it forms clumps. Keep it cold until you need it.
  3. Toss the apples with the sugar, flour, cinnamon, lemon juice, and salt.
  4. Pile the apples into the chilled crust, mounding them in the center, and pour in any juice left in the bowl.
  5. Scatter the crumb topping evenly over the apples.
  6. Set the pie on a sheet pan and bake 20 minutes at 400°F. Lower the oven to 375°F and bake 35 to 45 minutes more, until the juice bubbles thickly at the edges and a knife slides easily through the apples.
  7. If the top browns too fast, tent it loosely with foil. Cool at least 2 hours before slicing so the juices set.